Chapter 5 - The Price of Keeping Quiet
Vincent stared at his seventeen-year-old handwriting until the words began to look like a stranger's.
Father James had brought the hospital statement to Naomi's office in person. Carrie sat beside him, her bracelet resting on a folded cloth, and watched Vincent read. The paper had survived because the priest had copied it before the county collected the originals. The copy was faint but legible; an actual signed original would still need to be located.
"You remember her handing it to you?" Naomi asked.
"No. I remember taking it from the cabinet." He swallowed. "I remember opening the cabinet and the heat and getting dizzy. I don't know which parts are mine and which parts I've told myself since."
"Did Price ever talk to investigators?" he asked.
"Twice," Father James answered. "Her account changed between the first and second interview. She said she was offsite when the alarms started. Lena saw her near the storage passage. I didn't know that until yesterday."
Carrie had come prepared to confront Vincent, but a larger question now troubled her. "You said she handed you the flare. Where did she get it, and why would she give a kid something burning while the building was on fire?"
"You could ask her," Vincent said.
Naomi lifted a sheet from her file. "She's now the executive director of the Hawthorne Family Trust. The trust owns a minority interest in the holding company that manages your development fund."
The room went quiet.
Vincent looked at the ownership diagram. The connection had been disclosed in a merger appendix he signed the previous spring. He recognized his signature and the date. He had scanned the cover page, heard the benefits described at a meeting, and approved the acquisition while his team waited for lunch.
"Why wasn't I told?" he asked.
"You were," Naomi said quietly. "In writing."
"What does her trust receive?"
"A consulting fee tied to redevelopment milestones, including the St. Agnes site."
Carrie pushed away from the table. "She makes money when you clear the land?"
"Yes," Naomi said. "Whether it's an improper conflict is another question."
Carrie rounded on Vincent. "You said you didn't know her."
"I said I didn't pay her in 2007. I didn't know she was a beneficiary now."
"You sign checks for a living."
"That's true."
The next morning, Vincent called an emergency meeting of his board. Five directors sat around the conference table while Naomi explained the conflict. Vincent proposed suspending the demolition permanently until an independent investigation was complete. Three directors supported him. Two warned that suspending the project might breach financing agreements and trigger a costly default.
His chief operating officer, Martin Graves, studied the paperwork. "We can't simply shut down a contracted job and expect lenders to applaud. We can preserve the memorial, continue remediation elsewhere, and investigate in parallel."
"The basement passage is in the work zone," Vincent replied.
"Then seal that part. Don't freeze the entire site."
The compromise sounded sensible. It would protect the records room while allowing some work to continue. Vincent wanted a solution that didn't bankrupt the payroll of two hundred employees. He signed a narrow hold that covered the eastern foundation and permitted demolition on the western side.
That afternoon he called Carrie to explain. "I kept the records passage protected. The crew has written instructions."
"Is anyone independent watching?"
"A preservation specialist starts Monday."
"Today is Friday."
"My operations team knows what the order says."
"Your operations team sent a demolition instruction from your email yesterday."
Vincent bristled. "I've spent the past twenty-four hours stopping work at my own expense. You can't pretend I haven't."
Carrie closed her eyes. "I'm not pretending. I'm asking who pays if the only evidence gets destroyed before Monday."
He almost hung up. He almost told her she didn't understand what it took to keep a company running. Instead he said, "I'll send someone from legal to supervise tomorrow."
He intended to. Then another emergency arose: his lender demanded a personal guarantee to extend the debt while the city review proceeded. Vincent spent four hours negotiating. By the time he called Naomi, she had already left for a court filing in Kansas City.
At 6:18 Saturday morning, a subcontractor removing western retaining walls uncovered an old drainage pipe connecting directly to the sealed eastern passage. The backhoe operator saw a metal door behind it and reported the discovery to his foreman.
The foreman called Martin Graves, not Vincent. Martin read the narrow hold and decided the door lay just outside its marked boundary.
May you like
By eight o'clock, the metal door had been crushed.
And when Carrie arrived, she saw a stack of soot-blackened folders being loaded into a dumpster.
