Chapter 8 - The Costly Mistake
The mistake was Brooke's.
It came three weeks after the incident, after the investigation had begun and after Colonel Ross had been reassigned and after Major Hargrove had been arrested and after the general had told her she was going to be awarded the Soldier's Medal — after all of it — when she decided, in the way that soldiers who have been wronged sometimes decide things, that she was going to call the hunters.
She was not supposed to call the hunters. The investigators had told her not to. Her command had told her not to. Her lawyer — a young captain from the Fort Sill legal office named Marcus Reyes — had told her not to.
She called them anyway.
She had their names from the investigation file. She had their phone numbers from the police report. She had, in the moment of the incident, seen one of the hunters clearly through the range camera feed — a man in a bright orange vest who had been walking at grid 7-4-0 with three other men — and she had been unable to forget him. She had been unable to forget the way he had been walking. He had been walking in the way that a man walks when he does not know he is about to die.
She called him on a Tuesday afternoon in November.
His name was Walter Ellis. He was fifty-six years old. He was a dentist from Dallas. He had been hunting on the lease adjacent to the range for eleven years. He had, on the morning of the incident, paid Major Hargrove two hundred dollars in cash at the north gate, and he had driven into the impact zone with his three friends.
He answered on the third ring.
"Ellis."
"Mr. Ellis. This is Staff Sergeant Brooke Carter. I am the range safety NCO at Fort Sill."
There was a long pause.
"I know who you are," Ellis said.
"I want to tell you something."
"What?"
"I want to tell you that I am sorry."
Another pause.
"For what?"
"For the fact that you were on that range. For the fact that you were put in danger by an officer who should not have put you there. For the fact that you and your friends were almost killed by an artillery round that I did not fire. And for the fact that you have probably been having nightmares for three weeks and that I have not been able to do anything about it."
The line went silent.
"Mr. Ellis?"
"I am here."
"Mr. Ellis, I want you to know that the Army has changed its procedures. The Army has changed its procedures because of what happened on that range. The Army has made it so that a staff sergeant can call a ceasefire without needing approval from a colonel. The Army has made it so that no one can authorize a civilian pass to a range without three levels of verification. The Army has made it so that no one — not a colonel, not a major, not anyone — can put people in danger the way you and your friends were put in danger. I want you to know that. I want you to know that something good came out of that morning. I want you to know that even though I made a mistake by calling you — even though I was told not to — I needed to call you. I needed to hear your voice. I needed to know that you were okay."
There was a long silence on the line.
"Staff Sergeant Carter," Ellis said, and his voice was very quiet, "I want to tell you something. I have not slept for three weeks. I have been having the same dream every night. I am walking on a dirt road with my three friends. And I hear a sound. And I look up. And there is a shell coming at me. And I know that I am going to die. And then I wake up."
"Mr. Ellis—"
"I do not need your apology, Staff Sergeant. I do not need the Army's new procedures. I do not need anything. What I need is to sleep. And I have not been able to sleep because I have been thinking about the fact that the only reason I am alive is that a staff sergeant I have never met picked up a red flag and stopped the world."
The line went silent.
"Mr. Ellis," Brooke said, "I am the staff sergeant you have never met."
"I know."
"I stopped the world."
"I know."
"That was my job."
"That was your job." Ellis paused. "Staff Sergeant Carter, I want to tell you something. I have been a dentist for thirty years. I have never been in the Army. I have never been in combat. I have never been in a situation where anyone was going to be killed. And I have always — I want to be honest with you — I have always been a little bit skeptical of the military. I have always thought that the Army was a bureaucracy. I have always thought that soldiers were people who followed orders. And then I was in that range. And a colonel told you to give up your flag. And you did not give up your flag. And I want you to know that I will never be skeptical of the Army again. Not for the rest of my life. Because I saw a staff sergeant pick up a red flag and refuse to give it up. And that staff sergeant saved my life. And the lives of my three friends. And the lives of two soldiers and two more civilians."
"Mr. Ellis—"
"Staff Sergeant Carter, I am going to tell my grandchildren about you. I am going to tell them that there was a staff sergeant at Fort Sill who would not give up her flag. And I am going to tell them that she saved my life. And I am going to tell them that if they are ever in a position where someone is telling them to do something that is wrong, they should think about a staff sergeant at Fort Sill who said no."
Brooke was crying.
She did not know when she had started crying. She had been crying for a while. She had, at some point, sat down on the floor of her living room. She was holding the phone in one hand and her father's dog tags in the other.
"Mr. Ellis," she said, "thank you."
"Staff Sergeant Carter," Ellis said, "thank you."
The line went dead.
Brooke sat on the floor of her living room for a long time.
Then she stood up.
She went to the kitchen. She made a cup of coffee. She sat down at the kitchen table.
She picked up her phone and she called her lawyer.
"Captain Reyes," she said. "This is Staff Sergeant Carter."
"Staff Sergeant," Reyes said. "What is wrong?"
"Nothing is wrong. I need to tell you something."
"Go ahead."
"I called Walter Ellis. The hunter. On the range camera feed."
There was a long pause.
"Staff Sergeant Carter—"
"I know. I know I was not supposed to. I know it was a mistake. I know it is a violation of protocol. I know it could compromise the investigation. I am telling you because I want to tell you. And I want you to tell me what the consequences are going to be."
Reyes was quiet for a moment.
"The consequences," he said, "are that the Army is going to have to decide whether to charge you with a violation of investigative protocol. That is a very serious charge. It is a charge that could result in a written reprimand. It could result in a loss of promotion. It could result in a loss of your security clearance. It could result in a loss of your career. It could result in all of those things. It could result in none of them. It depends on what the Army decides to do. It depends on how the Army weighs your violation of protocol against the fact that you saved ten lives. It depends on the general. It depends on a lot of things. But I am going to tell you something, Staff Sergeant Carter."
"What?"
"I am going to tell you that I have been a JAG officer for six years. In those six years, I have defended soldiers who called witnesses they were not supposed to call. I have defended soldiers who confronted people they were not supposed to confront. I have defended soldiers who did things that were not in the rule book because they were trying to do the right thing. And I have never — not once — defended a soldier who did the right thing for the wrong reason. You called Walter Ellis because you needed to hear his voice. Because you needed to know he was okay. Because you are a staff sergeant, and because a staff sergeant checks on the people she has saved. That is not a violation of protocol. That is what a staff sergeant does."
"Captain—"
"I am going to fight for you. I am going to fight for you because you deserve to be fought for. And I am going to tell you right now — because I am going to be honest with you — the next three months are going to be the hardest three months of your career. Are you ready for that?"
"Yes, sir."
"Then go to sleep. Eat something. And do not — do not — call anyone else from that investigation file. Do you understand?"
"Yes, sir."
"Good night, Staff Sergeant Carter."
"Good night, Captain Reyes."
Brooke hung up the phone.
She sat at her kitchen table for a long time.
Then she went to bed.
She did not sleep. But she did not cry either. She lay in the dark and thought about Walter Ellis and about the three friends and about the two soldiers at grid 7-4-3 and about the two civilian drivers at grid 7-4-2.
And she decided, somewhere around two in the morning, that she had made the right call.
It had been a mistake. It had been a violation of protocol. It had been the wrong thing to do according to every rule in the Army.
But it had been the right thing to do according to what it meant to be a staff sergeant.
And she was not going to apologize for it.
Not to the Army. Not to the investigators. Not to anyone.
She was going to take whatever consequence the Army decided to give her. And she was going to take it because she was a soldier. And because a soldier does not lie. And because a soldier does not hide. And because a soldier takes the consequences of her actions even when her actions were right.
The Army investigated the phone call.
It determined that Staff Sergeant Carter had called Walter Ellis in violation of the investigative protocol. It determined that the call had not compromised the investigation. It determined that the call had not prejudiced the case. It determined that the call was, in the words of the investigating officer, "a technical violation of procedure committed by a soldier who was acting out of concern for a civilian who had been placed in danger by an officer under investigation."
The Army issued a formal reprimand.
The reprimand was placed in Staff Sergeant Carter's file.
It was amended six months later — after the Carter Regulation was signed and after the Soldier's Medal had been awarded and after the investigation had concluded — to add a single sentence.
The sentence said: "This reprimand is issued for a technical violation of investigative protocol. It reflects no finding of misconduct, and it should not be construed as a reflection on the character or the service of the soldier to whom it is addressed."
The reprimand stayed in her file for three years.
It was removed in the spring of the third year.
She was not promoted during those three years.
She was promoted to sergeant first class the year after the reprimand was removed.
May you like
She has never told anyone about the reprimand. Not her friends. Not her family. Not the soldiers she has trained. She has told one person. She told Walter Ellis, on a phone call on the fifth anniversary of the incident, and he said, "Staff Sergeant, I would have called me too."
She said, "I know, Mr. Ellis. I know."
