Chapter 3 - A House With Two Histories
A judge authorized a targeted search of the plumbing chase and related renovation records after investigators presented the badge discovery, its location, and the documented work-order irregularities. Jo was not part of the search team. She sat at home watching an old comedy Luis used to quote, unable to remember a single joke.
Kim called with periodic updates. The wall contained traces of older plaster beneath a newer layer, suggesting the pipe chase had been opened during renovations. Investigators recovered small fragments of packaging material and a contractor's fastener tag. The material could help establish when the badge was placed, but lab work would take time.
Jo met Elena for lunch. Elena brought a folder of photographs showing Luis carrying their daughter on his shoulders at the beach. The little girl was twelve now and remembered her father less clearly each year. Elena asked Jo not to tell the child about the badge until they had a better understanding of what it meant.
"I keep picturing him trapped behind that wall," Elena said. "I know it doesn't make sense. The badge was there, not him. But my brain keeps building pictures anyway."
"Mine too."
"Then let's not make them her pictures."
Jo agreed. It was another boundary she would have challenged a year ago. Luis's absence belonged to his wife and child in a way Jo's grief could never replace. She had been his partner, not the person who had to explain to a child why a father missed another birthday.
The property records were complicated. Marco had purchased the home through a holding company after Nathan Price's estate sold it. The renovation firm changed names halfway through the work. Work permits listed Evelyn as representative for both owner groups. Nathan had designed the earlier plumbing changes despite lacking current certification for certain structural modifications. City reviewers had raised questions about inspections signed before the work was completed.
Jo remembered Luis being angry about a permit that had been approved during a holiday weekend. "Nobody checked the stairwell," he'd told her. "They signed it from a desk." She had laughed and said people were paid to be lazy everywhere. He had answered that laziness became corruption when somebody died.
The memory made her ashamed. She had listened without asking what building he meant. She had assumed they'd have time to talk about it the next day.
A contractor named Melvin Shaw agreed to an interview. He had worked at the brownstone when Nathan owned it. He said the pipe chase had been altered twice: once to correct a leak, later to hide an electrical conduit that shouldn't have shared space with plumbing. Shaw had refused to certify the work. Somebody else signed the completion sheet after he left.
Shaw recognized the scratch on Luis's badge from the photograph police showed him. "A man in plain clothes came asking about the inspection," he said. "He showed me a badge, but I never wrote down the number. I thought he was from the city."
"Did you see what happened to him?" Kim asked.
"No. He asked me where the old service entrance was. I pointed downstairs. Then he went into the house. I didn't see him leave."
The statement placed a detective matching Luis's description at the house. It did not prove Marco knew him, and it contradicted the old missing-person timeline, which recorded Luis's last verified location across town. Somebody had assumed a location rather than verifying it.
May you like
That night Jo received a second anonymous message. This time it showed a photograph of the rear staircase with a date stamped two years earlier. A handwritten arrow pointed toward a boarded doorway beneath the kitchen.
The message said: YOU OPENED THE WRONG WALL.
